I'm going to say some things that may not be very popular, and I am saying them from a place of anger, so beware: if you are uncomfortable hearing a different opinion than your own, or if you are uneasy with my anger, you might want to stop reading right now.
In response to the recent mass shooting, I read some very disturbing posts on Facebook. One blamed the kids for not reporting that the shooter seemed to be having a hard time, and blamed their parents for not encouraging profiling. There is no other way to put this. It put people in boxes and told us we should all do the same to prevent violence, never mind that this shooter was a white, heterosexual male. This rant stated that the shooter should have been reported and then locked up before he did anything because he was clearly having a hard time and the solution to people having a hard time is to throw them in prison, which would have prevented the shootings. It went on to blame liberals who don't want to indiscriminately lock people up, as being the problem and said that if someone at school names another person as having an issue, that kid should be imprisoned. Another comment I read on Facebook indicated with joy that one community did imprison a student who appeared to be struggling with mental illness, thereby preventing him from shooting anybody.
I think I was almost as disturbed by the suggestions in these posts as I was by the shootings themselves for several reasons. First of all, if we set up situations where, when a kid doesn't like someone else, they can just "report" that child as being disturbed with the reaction that the child reported will then be imprisoned, we are inviting a whole different kind of very serious bullying. What happened to innocent until proven guilty? Are we now saying it is okay to imprison someone on the chance that they MIGHT hurt someone else? Forget proving guilt, this is even suggesting arresting someone before they have done anything wrong! And again, what an invitation to bullies. I can see it now. Bully says, "If you don't give me your money or do exactly what I tell you to do then I will report you as seeming 'off' and they will throw you in prison!" Bully says, "I don't like you - I'm going to get you thrown into prison just because I can!"
Second, and more importantly, if we start dealing with people who have problems, are disturbed, and are struggling by throwing them into a prison where undoubtedly their problems will be exacerbated and emphasized, we are creating the very villains we are hoping to prevent. What happens when they are released, then, from prison? Or are we thinking we just lock them up for life because they are mentally ill or are struggling? And if we expect them to eventually be released, are we thinking that because of their time in hell (no exaggeration here... I've visited enough prisons and talked with enough inmates to know that American prisons are hell, despite what certain media may tell us), they will be calmer, better able to handle the stressors in life, better qualified to deal with their anger and less likely to go on a shooting rampage?! We would have to be insane to believe this. Prison creates and hardens criminals, it increases rage, it cements hatred, and it gives people no skills for dealing with those feelings, make no mistake about that. When a child is struggling with mental illness, anger, depression, rage, and other problems they need help. Our prisons do not help people.
There are so many aspects of our society and culture that must be addressed here; so very many, starting with how we help one another, how we care for one another, and how we learn to love one another. People who are struggling should not be put into a box we call "other" or "bad" and then simply locked away. They are us: they are our family, they are our siblings and our parents and our children and they need us to help them. I write this from the personal experience of having kids who are "different". Yes, I admit it, my kids are different. They don't fit in in the same way many other kids do, they've gone through some hard things, they struggle at times, and they are sometimes bullied. I deal with this with counseling, love, resources, and as a result they are doing well in school, doing well at home, they are balanced and healthy, they have skills for dealing with their anger and pain, though they undoubtedly will always be a little "different". But many kids do not have those resources. And I can see it being all too easy for those kids without those resources to be thrown into prison for their pain. We have to stop separating ourselves into "us" and "them". We have to be willing to love people who are different from ourselves and to recognize that for a society to be truly healthy, everyone in it must be healthy. We have a responsibility to create the opportunities for care, opportunities for growth and learning. We have a responsibility to care for one another, and to heal ourselves in the healing of each other.
We also need to address our justice system and move into a more restorative justice model where both victims and offenders are recognized as needing help and healing, and are given the help to change and to heal. Societies that use restorative justice models have an extremely small recidivism rate: people learn how to be better, how to do better, which lowers crime in those places substantially. The victims also truly achieve healing, unlike our current system where they are often re-traumatized by the court processes. The revenge-punishment model we have for our prisons does NOT work to deter crime, to lessen crime or to help the victims.
Mental health care needs to be funded and seen as a priority. Again, we do this for all of us: when we create a society where people with mental health issues cannot afford or obtain help, we create societies where violence is inevitable. We also need to teach how to deal with anger and rage. That too is a mental health and emotional health issue that as a society we need to begin to address.
Gun control also must be addressed: yes, it must. But I will allow others who are more knowledgeable and articulate to speak on that at this point: there are so many who do so much better than I ever could. I will only say that from a Christian perspective, I see absolutely no justification for our turning towards violence as a solution. Jesus was clear that killing was never acceptable. He was clear about turning the other cheek. Our arming ourselves with weapons whose only purpose is destruction of another is antithetical to everything he taught about seeing the other, even our enemies, as people we are called to love. Period. And our responding to violence with more violence escalates the problems. It does not bring peace.
Perhaps more than anything else, these tragedies call us to show who we really are. Are we people who take seriously the call to love one another, even those we consider "enemies"? Or are we fear based people who want to destroy, put away, and get rid of anyone who is different than ourselves? It is truly worth thinking over.
No comments:
Post a Comment